top of page
13 Logo With Text Colored.png



The vital link between
food & hunger

Painesville and Mentor Battle Over 215 Acres in Ongoing Dispute

MENTOR, OH - A contentious debate between the cities of Painesville and Mentor over the fate of a 215-acre parcel of land located at the intersection of Brookstone and Shamrock Boulevards has been ongoing for weeks. This dispute, which has captured the attention of both communities for weeks, centers on divergent visions for the property's use and the broader implications for economic development, environmental conservation, and local governance.

Map of Painesville and Mentor land
Image: City of Painesville

Painesville, seeking to bolster its economic prospects, envisions the property as a keystone for future development opportunities within its jurisdiction. This perspective is driven by the city's ambition to attract business investments and job creation, leveraging the land's strategic location. Painesville Councilman Derrick Abney expresses a steadfast optimism about the ongoing dialogue between the two cities, emphasizing the importance of continued conversation for growth.

On the other hand, Mentor, the current owner of the land, champions a contrasting approach. The city's leadership, including Law Director Joseph Szeman, articulates a vision of preservation, aiming to maintain the land in its natural state. This stance is underscored by Mentor's desire to enact police and sanitation regulations to address illegal activities and enforce local ordinances through the Mentor Municipal Court.

The complexity of the situation is deepened by the property's location within Painesville's limits but ownership by Mentor, a scenario stemming from a legal settlement with Shamrock Business Center Ltd. This arrangement places the land under Painesville's zoning codes and municipal services, yet Mentor's control presents a barrier to Painesville's development plans. The contention also impacts the Riverside Local School District, with potential financial implications tied to the land's tax status and the district's revenue.

As both cities navigate this dispute, the conversation extends beyond local governance, touching on broader themes of regional development, environmental stewardship, and inter-municipal cooperation. Mentor's proposal to place the land in conservation challenges Painesville's economic aspirations, sparking debates over the best use of the land amidst concerns about job growth and infrastructure development.

The ongoing dialogue between Painesville and Mentor reflects a critical juncture in Northeast Ohio's urban and environmental planning. With both cities poised for another round of discussions, the outcome of this dispute will undoubtedly shape the region's landscape—literally and figuratively—for years to come.

The third reading of the ordinance concerning the land's future is scheduled in two weeks, marking a pivotal moment in this inter-city saga. As residents and stakeholders from both communities await the resolution, the broader implications for Northeast Ohio's development and conservation efforts loom large, underscoring the delicate balance between progress and preservation in urban planning.


join C13 banner.jpg


bottom of page