From Gilmore Girls Star Liza Weil to the Late Stacy Keach, a Dream Cast Makes Lost & Found in Cleveland Feel Like Coming Home
CLEVELAND, Ohio — The past rarely leaves a house all at once. It remains in the wallpaper someone never wanted to replace and in the chair that still faces a television younger visitors cannot imagine keeping. A familiar song comes on, and the room belongs to several generations at once.
The holiday blockbuster Lost & Found in Cleveland understands a room like that. It understands how something can be old without being over, how a person can be gone without becoming absent from everything, and how an ordinary day can contain more years than a calendar knows what to do with.
I watched the film three times before I could begin to explain why it felt so much like coming home.
At the State Theatre, Cleveland recognized itself, and the room answered back. Laughter sometimes swallowed the dialogue. Familiar places arrived on screen with the pleasure of someone we knew walking through a door. At a later viewing for the theatrical premiere, I began studying the craft and searching the edges of scenes. By the time I watched at home with my partner, I could finally let the pleasure of finding Cleveland give way to the experience of finding the people inside it.
The film had remained the same, but I had become available to more of it.
When I spoke with the film's writers and creators, Keith Gerchak and Marisa Guterman last week, I asked about something I could feel before I understood it. The televisions, furniture, clothing and routines seemed to have arrived from different decades, yet nothing appeared to be visiting from the wrong one. Everything belonged.
“We are existing in multiple time periods currently with technology,” Marisa said.
Her observation reaches beyond technology. One person’s childhood is still someone else’s living room. A style that has become nostalgic to one generation remains an everyday choice for another. The things we have declared obsolete continue doing their work in houses where nobody has asked them to stop.
Here in Cleveland, those years can live down the street from one another. They can share a kitchen. They can belong to different people standing in the same room, each recognizing a different part of home.
The film lets a detail become visible just long enough for a question to rise. When is this set? I finally understood the answer I had been reaching for during our conversation.
“It’s not set in the past or the present. It’s set in the good.”
The answer to the question of when, in the only sense that matters to me here, is always.
Good has no period costume. The relief of being welcomed does not belong to the decade in which someone first welcomed us. A room can feel safe to a child and, many years later, awaken that same safety in the adult who remembers being small there. The feeling survives the furniture. Sometimes the furniture helps it find us.
Marisa described wanting that recognition to reach beyond the childhoods already represented in the audience.
“There is a timelessness to it that I hope my daughter will enjoy in 20 years,” she said.
I cannot think of another film that brings me closer to what the word timeless must have been invented to hold. Its years remain visible, yet none of them can claim ownership of the feeling. The film makes a home for all of them.
Keith understood what I meant about the good. He had been describing the film’s arrival in a very different emotional climate.
“This is a film that is getting released in an age of cruelty,” he said.
There is courage in making something so willing to care. The film extends that willingness to people who might embarrass us, irritate us or remind us of parts of ourselves we would rather leave unexamined. Its warmth reaches into places where warmth is difficult to offer.
The story begins with the arrival of a televised, traveling antiques appraisal show cleverly named 'Lost & Found'. Across a single day, people bring their possessions toward the promise of being told what they are worth. A camera might turn toward them. An expert might recognize something everyone else overlooked. An ordinary life might acquire, for a moment, the shape of an occasion.
The comedy lives beautifully in that distance between expectation and experience. Hope can make otherwise sensible people magnificently unreasonable. Dignity becomes difficult to manage when something we desperately want is almost within reach. We laugh at the elaborate ways people prepare to be recognized because, somewhere beneath the absurdity, we recognize the preparation.
We have all rehearsed a version of ourselves for a moment we hoped would change our lives. The film knows how funny that can be. It also knows what the laughter is standing next to.
An object arrives on a table, and an entire private history arrives along with it. The expert can inspect the material and examine the workmanship, and the person across the table may be waiting for an answer to a question nobody has actually asked aloud.
Did it matter that I kept this? Does it matter that I am still hoping? What happens to the story if I am the last person who remembers it?
Keith described characters who are caught within their own lives, unable to move beyond what has held them there. Telling the stories of their objects becomes a way of telling truths about themselves.
The appraisal becomes a kind of permission. A person who arrived hoping to be seen on television might finally become visible to themselves.
That possibility depends on a cast capable of giving every life a weight beyond its usefulness to the plot. Dennis Haysbert, June Squibb, Stacy Keach and Liza Weil provide that weight with extraordinary generosity. Martin Sheen, Loretta Devine, Dot Marie Jones, Jon Lovitz, Jeff Hiller, Santino Fontana and Rory O’Malley help populate a world whose comic variety feels inseparable from its humanity. Esther Povitsky, Yvette Yates Redick and Benjamin Steinhauser extend its reach across different ages and experiences.
The star power is remarkable even before anyone speaks. Sheen brings an Emmy and a Golden Globe, Squibb an Oscar nomination, Keach a Golden Globe, and Fontana a Tony. Their careers have helped shape what generations of audiences recognize as great acting. Seeing them gathered within a debut feature makes the achievement feel almost improbable.
The timing carries its own poignancy. The film was shot early in 2023, before that year’s writers and actors strikes, and Marisa later explained that it became the last project many crew members worked on that year. Careers and livelihoods could turn on decisions made far beyond Cleveland. Against that uncertainty, the convergence of these particular people feels extraordinary to me. The journeys that brought them into their roles, and the discoveries they made once inside them, contain a story as absorbing as the one they tell on screen.
That alignment is what makes the word independent feel too small in my mouth. It describes the film’s origins, yet scarcely prepares me for what those origins produced. To my eyes, this is a spectacular major motion picture whose extraordinary cast, visual assurance and emotional precision come together so completely that I cannot imagine wanting a different version. If this is the standard other independent films are expected to meet, the bar has been set almost impossibly high. Everything that might have prevented this particular film seems, in the finished work, to have helped deliver it at exactly the right moment.
The film drew a record audience of 2,700 at its Cleveland International Film Festival screening in the State Theatre. I was inside that audience, and the feeling exceeded the number. The room seemed to recognize something it had been waiting to feel together. That abundance is what the phrase major motion picture means to me here. I am convinced this will become a new cult classic because it gives people something they will want to return to, and someone they will want beside them when they do.
The performances make the city feel full of lives continuing beyond the camera. Nobody appears to have started existing merely because it became their turn to speak.
Haysbert’s Marty Anderson moved me through the gentleness of his wanting. An actor so familiar to audiences through authority and assurance allows us to feel the exposure involved in having a dream. His presence makes that vulnerability especially affecting. We understand how much strength it can take to let another person see something we have not yet managed to become.
Haysbert’s arrival makes that convergence feel almost scripted. After another actor had to withdraw, a connection through choreographer Martin Cespedes brought the filmmakers back to the performer they had imagined in the role for years. Haysbert joined just 48 hours before filming began.
The longing ran in both directions. As I reported when the film premiered, Haysbert described Marty to Keith as a role he had dreamed of playing. The opportunity meant being trusted with a tenderness his familiar authority could conceal. Watching him, I feel the happiness of that recognition flowing both ways. The filmmakers found their Marty, and Haysbert found someone he had been waiting for the chance to become.
Sheen recognized something equally substantial in his own part. “Martin Sheen said he hadn’t done a monologue like that since West Wing,” Keith told me. For an actor whose President Josiah Bartlet made the spoken word feel capable of carrying the weight of a nation, the comparison is considerable. Here, that command of a room serves the intimate question of an object's worth. The voice we remember speaking from the presidency turns toward an ordinary life and gives it that same undivided attention.
Weil, known to Gilmore Girls viewers as Paris Geller, accomplished something different and, for me, quietly revelatory.
During my first two viewings, Sophie Mathers was my least favorite character. During my third, she was my favorite. I told Keith and Marisa that, and Marisa said she had chills.
“No one else could play Sophie but Liza Weil,” she said.
Marisa remembered Weil joining about eight days before filming. That narrow interval makes the completeness of her performance even more affecting. A casting decision made with so little time remaining produced a woman who seems to have been living inside this story for years.
I understood the certainty. Weil gives Sophie enough sharpness to keep us at a distance, then leaves enough loneliness visible for that distance to begin hurting. Her determination to control appearances becomes more complicated the longer we look. We start to wonder what might collapse if she stopped holding everything in place.
The performance does not ask us to pretend that being around Sophie would be easy. It allows us to imagine how exhausting it might be to live inside her.
She had not become a different woman on my third viewing. I had stopped letting my first judgment do all the watching.
One of the film’s most generous invitations is that it gives us time to become less certain about people.
The characters also change one another through the light their differences cast. Fontana’s Gary, a professor unsettled by an inherited collection of racist art, brings the distance between knowing about prejudice and confronting its inheritance into uncomfortable focus. I see that question echo in the contrast between Sophie’s social privilege and Marty’s quiet vulnerability as a Black mail carrier. Racism and class enter a story about appraisal through the unequal ways people themselves are seen and valued. Objects can preserve the ugliness of an earlier world as faithfully as they preserve its beauty, and a polished present can still carry the habits of that past.
Elsewhere, Maria and Charlie, played by Yvette Yates Redick and Benjamin Steinhauser, place a mother and child’s life beside the different partnership of Graham and Hugh, played by Jeff Hiller and Rory O’Malley. Their stories share the city with Sophie’s carefully maintained world and the long marriage embodied by Squibb and Keach. The lives are sometimes in opposition and sometimes unexpectedly complementary. Their proximity gives us another way to read each one. The perfect home begins to lose its single approved shape. Perfection becomes less a goal someone can display and more a feeling people can make possible for one another. I can feel that possibility moving through the film even when its characters are struggling to find it.
The same patience extends to Cleveland itself. Keith spoke about the city through the eyes of someone whose architectural work had included uncovering beauty beneath later facades. Older windows, stone and brick had survived behind the coverings that concealed them. What looked like discovery was, in another sense, recognition.
He recalled explaining the film’s locations to someone who assumed such interiors must have been constructed.
“No, this is what Cleveland looks like. That wallpaper is still there from 1960.”
There is something wonderfully funny about a city keeping its wallpaper long enough to surprise the movie business. There is something tender about it, too. A room does not stop belonging to the present because someone has loved it in the same way for a very long time.
Davon Slininger’s beautiful cinematography gives that recognition a visual life. Familiar streets and interiors become places worth lingering over, with room for the people inside them to belong to the city’s beauty. It is possible to spend a lifetime loving Cleveland and still need someone to show it back to you. Watching, I feel the happiness of finding it again after losing some part of it to familiarity. The title begins to describe the audience’s journey, too. We have been watching people carry treasures into a room while the film quietly places our own city back into our hands.
Keith’s larger hope was that Cleveland might recognize its own value without waiting for someone elsewhere to certify it.
“You can be the star of your own story,” he said.
In a film built around appraisal, that sentence feels especially consequential. A city can spend years carrying itself to an imaginary table, hoping an authority will finally announce that it deserves attention. These filmmakers have given Cleveland the sustained intimacy of being looked at with affection. Its beauty includes the things its people have been taught to apologize for keeping.
Their own persistence is part of what makes that affection credible. Marisa described a screenplay that came together in roughly three weeks, followed by a filmmaking journey that demanded years.
“Now, the filmmaking side of it took ten years, so there isn’t an accidental detail,” she said.
The finished film contains both the immediacy of inspiration and the devotion required to protect it. A story about people holding on to something meaningful was itself something two people refused to stop holding.
Our discussion of Keach brought the cost of time into sharper focus. He had died the day before we spoke, at 85. The film’s relationship with memory had acquired a new and terrible immediacy for the people who made it.
“His eyes in the movie are so powerful,” Marisa said.
She was speaking about his performance as Will Sokolowski, a Korean War veteran living with dementia. She described an actor who understood the character from within, even when that understanding required questioning a direction on the page. He knew whether Will could inhabit the present well enough to sit and read a newspaper.
He also rejected a brown toupee that had been intended for the scenes returning to the war. His older face remains before us in those moments, and that choice had troubled and moved me every time I watched.
I could feel why it mattered. Will is experiencing something that has become present to him. The years we can see upon his face offer no protection from the moment he is living through. We are looking at a man who has grown old and a wound that has not.
Beside that performance, Squibb gives the shared life around him an aching human scale. A long marriage contains the person before us and the person we remember, sometimes within the same look. Love must find a way to speak across that distance. The film allows us to feel how much of a lifetime can be held inside an ordinary moment between two people.
Keach’s death also changed what it meant for Marisa to encounter him again on screen. She spoke about the difficulty of believing someone was gone while his presence remained so immediate in the work.
I understood that dissonance. Death tells us there will be no more, and a film answers with a voice that speaks. A face enters the room exactly as it did before. For a moment, the heart recognizes its person before the mind can explain the terms of the visit.
The comfort is real; so is the devastation of remembering why we need it.
Marisa told me that the little blue house used as Charlie’s home no longer exists. It survives in the film, within the world she and Keith made, where a door can still open onto a place the city has lost.
Her description of that world stayed with me. She called it a “very protected space of good where Charlie’s house exists, and Stacy Keach is still alive.”
The good I had been trying to name suddenly had an address.
It was there in the house that could still be visited and in the performance that could still be encountered. The film could not prevent the losses outside its frame. It had preserved something we could return to after they happened.
As our conversation moved toward the holidays, Keith spoke about deaths in his own family.
“There are people that I did celebrate the holidays with last year who are not here this year,” he told me.
He described inherited objects as “a tether to the people that we have lost.”
The word tether feels exact. Something remains attached. We can continue moving through our lives and still feel the gentle resistance of a love that has not agreed to become past tense.
An ordinary possession can undo us that way. We turn it over, recognize a mark or a repair, and discover that our hands remember something we had not prepared to feel. Its price becomes almost absurd beside the cost of being the one who must decide what happens to it now.
A room can lose its heart without losing a single piece of furniture.
The holidays ask us to enter those rooms again. We prepare the food and repeat the familiar motions. We discover how much of a celebration once depended on someone whose contribution we mistook for the natural order of things. A memory makes us laugh, and the laugh opens the place where the absence lives.
Keith described the people he had lost as remaining present in his heart and his memories. They still belonged to the celebration, even when he could no longer gather with them in the same way.
“They still have a place at the table in my brain and around the tree,” he said.
That is the kind of hope this film understands. We can make room for someone without pretending the chair is occupied. We can be grateful for what remains and devastated by what does not. The feelings can share the table because we have to live with both.
“Grief is fundamentally human, and it will touch everybody,” Marisa said.
Her film gives that truth somewhere to sit. It lets grief belong to a child as fully as it belongs to someone who has carried it for decades. It lets comedy continue in its presence. The laughter feels warmer for having somewhere honest to return from.
I think that is why the film’s happiness reaches me so deeply. It has made room for everything that could have prevented it.
I told Keith and Marisa that trying to describe their work had changed the way I experienced other films. I had always trusted words to help me reach a feeling. This time, the feeling kept asking more of the words.
I have come to know and care about the people who made this film through covering it. What continues to move me about their work is how generously it makes room for people they will never meet. A stranger can arrive carrying a private sorrow and find something recognizable there. Another can come for the comedy and leave having looked more kindly at someone they thought they understood.
I call Lost & Found in Cleveland a masterpiece because it has continued doing its work after the screen goes dark. Sophie has made me question a judgment. Will has made me consider what another person may be living through while I assume we occupy the same moment. The objects have made me think about the hands that held them before they reached the table.
In beautifully subtle ways, the film has shown me that attention is a form of love.
I want to watch it again with people I love, while we can still gather in the same room. I want to hear where they laugh. I want to discover which detail belongs to their childhood and which character has quietly found them. I want the ordinary happiness of being together to have its full weight before memory has to carry it for us.
Someday, one of us may take a blanket down from a shelf and remember the hands that pulled it across our knees. A whole evening can come back in the time it takes to unfold it.
For now, we can still move over on the couch. The film can begin, and all our different years can settle into the same room.
It will be set in the good; and for as long as the light from the screen paints the faces beside me, the good will be happening now.
---------------
Lost & Found in Cleveland is available to stream on Amazon Prime video.



























































Comments